That 'Terrible' Idea in Your Head Is Someone's Million-Dollar Solution
Welcome back. Today I want to tell you about Derek Sivers, because his story will piss you off and inspire you in equal measure.
Derek had a band in the 90s. Like every musician who wasn't Nirvana, he wanted a record deal. He sent demo CDs everywhere. Made calls that went nowhere. Played showcase nights where the A&R guys never showed.
Finally, he gave up on getting signed and built a website to sell his own CD. Basic stuff—shopping cart, payment processing, done. He sold maybe five copies.
Then Marcus Miller called. Bass player from another Portland band. He'd heard about Derek's site through the local scene.
"Can I sell my CD on there too?"
Derek shrugged. "Sure. Thirty-five bucks to set up a page."
Word spread through coffee shops and dive bars. More musicians called. Derek kept saying yes. Thirty-five dollars each time. No contracts, no revenue splits. Just a way for artists to sell direct to fans.
Music industry people told him he was wasting his time. Unknown bands don't sell records online. Real money comes from radio, record stores, major labels. His little side project would never amount to anything.
Derek ignored them.
He kept adding bands. Five became fifty became five hundred. Some sold dozens of CDs. Others sold hundreds. A few hit thousands.
Twelve years later, Derek sold CD Baby for twenty-two million dollars.
Those same industry experts were still explaining why online music sales would never work while Derek cashed checks from two hundred thousand musicians who'd built careers through his "worthless" platform.
When Smart People Miss Obvious Solutions
Brian Chesky and Joe Gebbia were broke in San Francisco, 2007. Couldn't make rent. A design conference was coming to town, hotels were booked solid, and they had a stupid idea.
They bought three air mattresses at Target, inflated them in their apartment, posted a Craigslist ad. "Air Bed and Breakfast." Eighty bucks a night, breakfast included.
Three people paid. Rent was covered.
When they pitched this as a business, VCs laughed them out of rooms. Who sleeps in strangers' houses? Hotels exist for reasons—safety, standards, insurance, reliability.
Paul Graham at Y Combinator was blunt: "Worst idea we've ever funded."
Brian and Joe weren't solving hospitality industry problems. They were solving their own problem, and thousands of emails proved others shared it.
They kept building. One booking, one host, one city at a time.
Airbnb is worth seventy-five billion. Marriott and Hilton still don't understand what hit them.
Jeff Bezos had the same experience. He told his Wall Street boss he wanted to quit and sell books from his garage.
His boss thought he'd lost his mind. Bookstores had perfected book selling. People needed to browse shelves, discover authors, get recommendations. Reading was tactile—customers wanted to touch books before buying.
Jeff listened, then drove to Seattle and started packing books anyway.
He wasn't recreating bookstores online. He was solving selection. Physical stores carried thirty thousand titles. Online could offer millions without inventory.
Amazon launched with one million books. Barnes & Noble's biggest store had one seventy-five thousand.
Amazon is worth 1.7 trillion. Barnes & Noble filed bankruptcy. Borders died.
Your Brain Works Against You
There's a mental trap that catches everyone with good instincts. Your brain dismisses your best ideas because they feel too simple.
The logic: If you thought of it, someone smarter tried it already. If it seems easy, it can't be valuable. If the solution feels obvious, it's probably worthless.
This isn't protecting you from failure. It's protecting you from success.
Drew Houston kept losing files. USB drives fell out of pockets, got left in computers, died at bad moments. Email had size limits. FTP required tech knowledge most people lacked.
He wanted files available everywhere. Simple.
Tech investors told him cloud storage was solved. Microsoft had SkyDrive. Google had Drive. Apple had MobileMe. Giants with unlimited budgets owned the space.
Drew didn't build better technology. He built something people could actually use. Install software, drag files to folder, access anywhere. Done.
Two gigs free, more space for referrals. Simple growth, simple product.
One million users in seven months. Eight billion dollar valuation today. Most "superior" competitors failed because they were too complicated for normal humans.
When Being Smart Hurts
Smart People overcomplicate simple problems. Intelligence becomes a liability when it talks you out of obvious fixes.
Travis Kalanick wasn't a transportation expert. He just wanted reliable rides in San Francisco. Taxis were unreliable. Dispatch meant twenty minutes on hold. Cash-only payments created awkward negotiations.
He built an app. Request ride, track driver, pay automatically. No cash, no waiting, no uncertainty.
Transportation consultants explained why ride-sharing couldn't work. Complex regulations varying by city. Prohibitive insurance for individual drivers. Weeks-long background checks. Vehicle standards. Hostile unions.
Regulatory barriers would kill any startup.
Travis didn't understand why barriers were insurmountable. He solved them city by city, problem by problem, as they came up instead of anticipating everything.
Started with black cars and professional drivers in SF. Expanded to regular cars with part-timers. Then other cities. Each expansion taught him regulations, insurance, operations.
Uber is worth ninety billion. Most taxi companies went bankrupt perfecting systems customers hated.
When Expertise Creates Blindness
The more you know about an industry, the less you see how it could work better. Knowledge creates blind spots outsiders exploit.
Sara Blakely was getting dressed for a party. White pants showed panty lines. She grabbed pantyhose, cut off the feet with scissors. Problem solved—smooth lines without full pantyhose discomfort.
Every woman she knew had this problem. Everyone tried similar desperate fixes—cutting, tucking, layering. Universal frustration, no commercial solution.
She called hosiery manufacturers about footless pantyhose. They explained why it wouldn't work commercially.
Ten thousand unit minimums per style. Thousands in setup costs. Retail buyers required established relationships and proven sales. Marketing budgets to compete with major brands.
Barriers designed to keep small players out.
Sara didn't know she was supposed to stay out. She called until one manufacturer agreed to a small batch. Drove to Neiman Marcus, pitched the buyer directly. Demonstrated in dressing rooms, showing women the difference.
Spanx launched with five thousand dollars, no business plan. Sara handled everything—development, sales, marketing, service. Oprah appearance generated millions overnight.
1.2 billion dollar company today. Hosiery giants still catching up to products they should have invented decades ago.
Problems Hiding Everywhere
Every industry tolerates obvious problems because fixing them seems beneath attention. These ignored frustrations are opportunities waiting for someone naive enough to try.
Melanie Perkins was designing her university yearbook. Photoshop cost six hundred bucks and required months of training. InDesign was more complex. QuarkXPress was built for print shops, not students.
Basic design shouldn't need a computer science degree. Anyone should create attractive layouts without semester-long software training.
Design experts explained why simple tools wouldn't work. Professionals needed precise typography control, color management, print specifications. Serious design required serious software with advanced capabilities.
Simplification meant limitation. Limitations meant inferior results professionals wouldn't accept.
Melanie wasn't serving professionals. She wanted to help normal people create good-looking stuff—social posts, presentations, flyers, invitations, business cards.
Canva: drag-and-drop simplicity. Pre-made templates. Built-in photos. Automatic sizing for platforms. Everything non-designers needed, nothing they didn't.
Professionals dismissed it as a toy. Non-designers created millions of designs they never could have made with professional software.
Forty billion dollar valuation. Adobe scrambling to build simplified versions because they finally realized most people don't want professional complexity for basic tasks.
The Ten-Second Truth Test
Want to know if your idea might be worth billions? Explain it to a kid. If a ten-year-old gets both problem and solution immediately, you might have something.
Revolutionary ideas need complex explanations. Simple ideas that solve real problems explain themselves.
"Watch videos online." YouTube. Google bought it for 1.65 billion. "Share photos instantly." Instagram. Facebook paid one billion. "Buy stuff without leaving home." Amazon. 1.7 trillion value. "Get rides without calling taxis." Uber. Ninety billion worth.
Each felt embarrassingly obvious to their creators. Too simple to matter. Too basic for businesses.
Complexity came in execution—infrastructure, scaling, edge cases. Core insight stayed simple.
Your Problem Is Your Product
Best business ideas solve problems you live with personally. You understand the frustration completely. You know what doesn't work. You spot what's missing because you deal with it daily.
Stewart Butterfield's team was building a video game called Glitch. They couldn't communicate effectively during development. Email too slow. Phone calls interrupted workflow. Chat tools were clunky, unreliable.
Built internal messaging that worked for their team. Organized conversations by topic. Searchable history. File sharing that didn't break. Non-annoying notifications.
Other companies heard about their tool, asked to use it. Stewart realized team communication was bigger than gaming.
Shut down the game. Focused on messaging.
Slack sold to Salesforce for 27.7 billion.
Kevin Systrom wanted simple photo sharing. Existing apps were slow, complicated. Built Instagram for instant, beautiful photo sharing. Facebook bought it for one billion.
Your daily frustrations are market research. Personal solutions are product development. Obvious ideas are business opportunities waiting for someone brave enough to build them.
Competition Proves Markets Exist
Most people quit when they find competition. This backwards thinking kills more fortunes than economic crashes.
Competition doesn't kill markets—it validates them. Proves people want solutions enough to pay. Question isn't whether competitors exist, but whether you can build something people prefer.
Richard Lowe helped a LinkedIn expert write a personal branding book. LinkedIn advice saturated everything. Hundreds of books on Amazon. Thousands of articles everywhere. Millions of social posts sharing LinkedIn tips.
Every angle covered. Every strategy explained. Every tip shared multiple times.
Book sold fifteen thousand copies in three days anyway. Hit forty-three in all Kindle sales. Built six-figure consulting business in "oversaturated" market.
Difference wasn't the advice—LinkedIn strategies are standard. Difference was approach. Simple tactics delivering immediate results instead of complex theories that sounded impressive but didn't work.
People don't want more information. They want better results. Competition often means more complexity, not better solutions.
Perfect Kills Profit
Amazon started as basic book website from Jeff's garage. No recommendations. No one-click buying. No Prime. Just books, prices, working cart.
Facebook launched with profile pages and friend connections. No timeline. No feed. No ads. Just college students connecting with classmates.
Twitter began as short status updates. No hashtags. No retweets. No trending. Just 140-character broadcasts.
Each started with most basic version of obvious idea. Advanced features came later, driven by user needs not founder assumptions.
Your idea doesn't need perfection at launch. Needs to exist and solve real problems people pay to fix.
The Clock Never Stops
Marcus Sheridan's pool company was bleeding money in 2008. Three months from bankruptcy. Instead of waiting to become marketing expert, he started answering customer questions online. Blog posts about algae, repairs, chemicals. Basic pool owner stuff.
Writing wasn't perfect. Marketing knowledge limited. No content strategy. But he helped people solve problems, they chose his company over silent competitors.
Today Marcus charges twenty-five thousand for single consulting days. His book sits on Fortune 500 desks. Conference organizers pay premium speaking fees for insights he developed saving his failing business.
Didn't wait for perfect knowledge. Started with obvious problems he'd already solved.
Every day you spend preparing, someone else starts with less preparation but more courage.
What You Know Is Enough
Stop hunting for revolutionary world-changing ideas. Start with obvious problems you solve naturally without thinking.
What industry frustration do you navigate daily that overwhelms newcomers? What simple workaround do you use automatically while others complain constantly? What obvious solution exists that nobody built properly because they're too close to see clearly?
Three problems you solved this year. Write them down. Not innovations or discoveries. Simple fixes that made life better, cost almost nothing to implement.
One affects thousands who'd pay for your solution. One deserves attention and could generate revenue. One represents genuine opportunity if you build instead of think.
Do This Right Now
Open something to write in. Phone notes, Google doc, paper napkin.
Write "Problem:" Describe one thing that frustrated you this week. One sentence.
Write "Solution:" Explain how you fixed it. Another sentence.
If a ten-year-old understands both, you found potential business. If you'd pay for that solution, others will too. If you can build basic version without engineering team, you have everything needed.
Stop waiting for expert permission, perfect timing, revolutionary insights that may never come.
Build obvious solution to obvious problem.
Your Move
Derek's "pointless" music site made twenty-two million. Brian's "ridiculous" air mattresses became seventy-five billion company. Jeff's "doomed" online bookstore built 1.7 trillion empire.
None had perfect ideas. All had obvious solutions to obvious problems experts said wouldn't work.
Your terrible idea isn't terrible. It's obvious.
Obvious solutions to real problems build the biggest fortunes.
Someone will build your idea. Make sure it's you.
The Writing King can help document your solution and establish authority while you build, but don't let that become another delay excuse.
What obvious problem have you been ignoring that could be worth millions? Hit reply—I read everything and sometimes share the best ideas.
Know someone making excuses instead of building? Forward this. Not subscribed? [Subscribe here] for more on turning expertise into income.